Reviews for Touching the Void
Review - Touching the Void
OK, this was an impressive story about two tough men. The way the partnered up to get Simpson down from the peak with a broken leg was noteworthy. I can imagine how Simon felt cutting the rope and leaving his friend behind, and I can almost imagine how tough Simpson must have been to deal with the pain of a shattered leg while crawling for three days.
And yet it was all unnecessary and reckless and egotistical and stupid. The mountain had been climbed before. That it hadn't been climbed by their particular route means nothing. Nobody has ever walked around my block wearing waffle irons instead of shoes while singing songs from Mary Poppins loudly. That doesn't mean doing so is an accomplishment.
It's not that these guys want to climb mountains that bothers me — just their aura of superiority, as though what they're doing matters.
And yet it was all unnecessary and reckless and egotistical and stupid. The mountain had been climbed before. That it hadn't been climbed by their particular route means nothing. Nobody has ever walked around my block wearing waffle irons instead of shoes while singing songs from Mary Poppins loudly. That doesn't mean doing so is an accomplishment.
It's not that these guys want to climb mountains that bothers me — just their aura of superiority, as though what they're doing matters.
Reviewed by Roger on 2015-03-04 15:08:23