Garden of Evil

directed by Henry Hataway
Category: "Western"
Year of Release:1954
Date Added:07/20/2025
Date Watched:11/03/2025
Description:Three men on their way to California, Hooker (Gary Cooper), Fiske (Richard Widmark, and Daly (Cameron Mitchell), are stranded in a Mexican port when their ship breaks down. Leah (Susan Hayward) shows up minutes after they arrive and offers them lots of gold if they ride into the wild with her and save her husband who is stuck in a gold mine. A random Mexican comes with them. As they ride, Daly makes a play for Leah and gets beaten up by Hooker. When they get to the mine, they rescue Fuller (Hugh Marlowe) in about 11 seconds. He has a broken leg, which Hooker fixes. Meanwhile Daly and the Mexican dig for gold and get all excited. Then Apaches show up, and the group takes off in a hurry. Fuller realizes he's a drag with his broken leg, so he takes off alone and gets killed. Then Daly is shot. Then the Mexican. The remaining three take a stand on a ledge. Hooker and Fiske (who is a gambler) draw cards and Fiske wins the right to stay and fight the Indians while Hooker and Leah ride to safely. Hooker sees that Leah is safe and goes back to kill the last two Indians (although how he knew this and why they stuck around until the very last one was dead, I'm not sure). He finds Fiske dying of an arrow wound. He tells Fiske he's a good man. Fiske tells Hooker to take Leah and make a home. Hooker rides back and joins Leah.
My Rating:5

Reviews for Garden of Evil

Review - Garden of Evil

Maybe it was just the copy of the movie I watched, but most of the landscape looked fake to me, often purple. The plot was melodrama, with Fuller, Daly, and Fiske all commenting on how Leah wound men around her finger—even though it seemed to me that all she did was try to save her husband who just berated her. I think we're supposed to assume Hooker and Leah ended up together (the film is called a romance), but there wasn't much chemistry to go on. It seemed like the entire plot hinged on the sultry allure of women and gold, although nobody seemed to end up with any god, and although I like Susan Hayward, she didn't act very alluring. It felt like a fable more than a story. Cooper did have one good line at the end: "If the world was made of gold, men would probably die for a handful of dirt."
Back to the list