Custer Fell Here

by Brian C. Pohanka, Sandy Barnard, James S. Brust
Category: "World History - Military"
Pages:187
Year of Publication:2005
Date Added:07/26/2006
Date Read:06/04/2006
Notes:Subtitle: Photographs of the Little Bighorn Battlefield Then and Now

The authors gathered a lot of photographs of the battlefield taken between 1877 (a year after the battle) and the 1950s, then spent ten years searching the area to take companion photographs from the same locations. An introduction gives short biographies of the major photographers. Then, in chapters based on different sections of the battlefield, the authors explain the probable events of the battle, identify the various terrain features and markers and show how the battlefield has changed over the years.
My Rating: 7

Reviews for Custer Fell Here

Review - Custer Fell Here

Why I read the book: I’ve read a lot about the battle, but I didn’t have a good feel of what the area looked like. (I didn't even know there was a four-foot fence on the battlefield!)I also enjoy then-and-now photograph comparisons, so this book was a natural.

What I liked about the book: I have a much better feel for the site. The photographs do a good job of showing how remote and bleak the area was — and is. I read histories of the battle recently enough that I can now place the events in the proper locations. I also have a very good sense of the location and appearance of the four-foot fence.

What I didn’t like about the book: OK, I’m a Custer junkie, but this book got redundant, even for me. It wasn’t necessary to point out the four-foot black fence around the last-stand area in every photograph in which it appeared, particularly when dealing with the part of the field inside the fence.

The least interesting quote: The four-foot fence around the markers on the hillside can be seen in this image.

Recommendation: If you like then-and-now photographs, if you want to see what the Little Bighorn Battlefield looks like, if you enjoy photos of horse bones, or if you want to see the four-foot fence for yourself, this book is for you. For the photographs and the sense of the area, I enjoyed it, but the redundancy brought my rating down to a 7.
Back to the list