Reviews for The Dark Frigate
Review - Dark Frigate, The
Supposedly groundbreaking in that it was one of the first books written for kids that portrayed life as difficult. It won the Newbery Medal in 1923.
I found it rather tedious. The author's attempt to use the language of the times failed often, with accents and styles of speech coming and going all the time. The pirates were decidedly incompetent also. After taking over Philip's ship, they attacked another ship and were beaten off, twice attempted to take a Spanish town and were beaten off twice and then attacked the man-o-war that got them captured and hung. I never cared enough about Philip's character to care what happened to him, and other characters appeared that had little or no bearing on the advancement of the plot.
I found it rather tedious. The author's attempt to use the language of the times failed often, with accents and styles of speech coming and going all the time. The pirates were decidedly incompetent also. After taking over Philip's ship, they attacked another ship and were beaten off, twice attempted to take a Spanish town and were beaten off twice and then attacked the man-o-war that got them captured and hung. I never cared enough about Philip's character to care what happened to him, and other characters appeared that had little or no bearing on the advancement of the plot.
Reviewed by Roger on 2015-04-05 18:48:28