phoenicopterus (from Greek, red-winged) ruber (Latin, red)
Adams County, Wisconsin – Pentenwell Lake
Sunday, October 8, 2023 – 1:18 pm
In my last post, I reported my failed trip to Alabama to see American Flamingos that were blown there by a recent hurricane. On the very day I was striking out in Alabama, birders found three adults and two juveniles on Pentenwell Lake in central Wisconsin. The lake is man-made, part of the Wisconsin River flowage, and is very close to Necedah National Wildlife Refuge where Whooping Cranes breed. It just so happened that we were heading north to spend a week in Rhinelander. I kept watching the eBird reports to see if these birds would hang on until I got there. I really didn’t expect them to.
They almost didn’t. We arrived around 1:00 pm on a cool, cloudy day. The lake was large – about two miles across. A family from Illinois was already there looking for the flamingos. They had been told by another birder that the birds were still there. The father, Ben, pointed to the area of the lake where they had supposedly been seen. There were some white spots along the shore that Ben thought might be the birds. After exchanging phone numbers to keep each other up to date on what we were seeing, he and his family took off to try to get closer. Sally and I stayed where we were. I soon became convinced that the white spots were foam on the shore. They certainly weren’t flamingos.
I started scanning the far shore with my scope and soon found what I was convinced was a flamingo. I couldn’t see much because the distance created haze that made everything dance. Sally and I thought we could see the bird preening, but most of the time it stayed in the same place not doing much. We also thought we saw some pinkish color on the bird.
Meanwhile Ben and family returned. They had met some kayakers who had paddled along the far shore. They said there was only one flamingo in view, right where I had been looking. The other four birds had apparently taken off and, so far as I know, were not found again.
I let Ben use my scope, and of course while he was looking, the bird flapped. He said he could see black on the wings. Pretty soon it became even more evident that we were looking at a bird because it began moving through the shallows. I could make out a long-legged, long-necked wading bird with black on the sides. I could also make out flamingo-like feeding movements as it slowly worked through the shadows. There is no way I could have identified it as a flamingo if others hadn’t found it first, but since they had, I feel confident in my identification – especially since I found the photos the kayakers took of the very bird we saw at the very time we had been looking for it.
Here are my best photos. Make of them what you will.
When you compare them to the kayakers’ photos (which I post here, having “borrowed” them online), you can sort of make out what I was seeing. There is some pink on the bird, but I don’t know if we were really seeing it from two miles away or not.
Somebody else saw them from the same place we did, about two hours after we left, but nobody saw it again later on that day or on any other day. So I missed the Alabama birds by four hours after they were there a month, missed four of the five Wisconsin birds by a day after they were there about a week, and saw this one just a couple hours before it was last seen. It wasn’t a very satisfying view, but I have no doubt about what we saw.
American Flamingos are rare in south Florida – straying up occasionally from their range in the Caribbean. To see them in Wisconsin is almost unbelievable. But that’s what makes birding such a fun hobby. You just never know.
I found out later these birds were from the Yucatan Peninsula in Mexico.
Update: In late March, 2025, I took a 10-day birding trip to Georgia and Florida. Halfway through my trip, I spent part of a day at Merritt Island National Wildlife Refuge. A flock of flamingos had been hanging out near an island in the Indian River in the refuge and had been seen by 100s (probably 1000s of birders). I guessed it might be my luck that they would leave before I had a chance to see them, but they didn’t. I parked in the nearest lot and actually waded along the shore to get to the closest spot to the birds I could find without renting a boat. I was still a long way away, but this time, there could be no doubt about what I saw.
As for missing them, as I write this update on May 18, the birds are still there.
























































